On Initiations and other Rites of Passage

[From Purple Reign - purplewildcats.com]

I'm sure we're all disturbed
by the reports that the Northwestern Women's Soccer team conducted what appears to be Hazing prior to the start of the season last Summer. Pictures posted on the internet last summer appear to show young women in various stages of undress, performing well, you know.

Given all the controversy surrounding the Duke Men's Lacrosse team and their "party," NU AD Mark Murphy reacted swiftly and decisively in suspending the team. Assistant AD for Media Services, Mike Wolf was quoted in USA Today's story, that "The Duke (incident) just reinforced the sensitivity."

The Women's soccer team, under head coach Jenny Haigh, had been been rebounding a bit - they finished 9-9-1 last year, and I'm sure the coaches, while not condoning hazing, probably did encourage the players  [especially the team's captains] to help develop a sense of team to play, study and party together.
As a survivor
of both fraternity and Navy Chief Petty Officer initiations, I can assure you that one man's hazing can be another's "rite of passage" into a select group. As part of that rite, people are put into varied, stressful situations to demonstrate to the rest of the group their ability to adapt. Who knows, they may be working some day in a life or death situation. The CPO initiation ends with a ceremony that explains why the events of the previous months were so important to the success of the group. Most Chiefs would vote to never eliminate this part of Navy tradition.

Its also interesting that under NU's hazing policy [based on Illinois law], military boot camp, survival training, infantry school, Army parachute jump school and various Special Forces training evolutions would be prohibited.

But its easy for kids who don't understand the difference between creating a "rite of passage," and hazing, torun afoul of the authorities.

Most fraternity initiations are held with alumni present, and Senior Enslisted closely monitor events at their "initiations." They provide a tempering force and the rule at most of these events is "what happens here, stays here." [Almost all Navy CPOs will only talk about their initiation with other CPOs.]

I wasn't at the Soccer party, don't know anyone who was there and I doubt we'll ever know who crossed the line, and when they crossed it, if they actually did commit "hazing."

Of course I'm sure there will be those who will point to some "evil atmosphere" in all college athletics, with the "porn curriculum," supposedly taught at NU, as one source of inspiration for the events.
But then I have another problem about all this.
The web site that "broke the story," Badjocks.com, is one of those sites that claims to find humor in the various legal infractions by college and pro athletes - their motto is "Where COPS meets SportsCenter."

Right now, they're advertising their "Dirty Dozen," 12 more colleges that will have their "initiation pictures" posted. The site also features links to online gambling, including a sports betting service, and DUI lawyer referral services.

They have a Blood Alcohol Ranking - listing the 10 highest BAC readings by athletes, and even a "Badjocks Scoreboard" showing counts of various athletes infractions. I'm sure they all watch sports on TV, they just don't like the so-called elitist attitude, or is it they don't like some people they consider inferior to succeed, Hmmmm

I call the time between College Football Spring Games and the start of summer camp, Police Blotter time — its when every infraction by any college athlete gets "top of the sports page" billing because there's no other team news.

Some of these infractions are serious and point up issues of personal responsibility, others, would not be reported if the kid hadn't been an athlete. Look at the "police blotter" section of your local newspaper - how many of those calls make the front page?

You see, I really don't see any good reason to drag any public person's reputation through the mud.

To condem the entire college athletic process because some party pictures got on the internet is just plain wrong!

I hope the NU investigation of all this, leads to a better understanding of the issue, and not just the finding of a scapegoat.

 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this post.
Comments
  • No comments exist for this post.
Leave a comment

Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Enter the above security code (required)

 Name

 Email (will not be published)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.